Summary
This proposal calls for transforming the KSC Visitors Center and Cape
Canaveral Air Force Station into a world-famous tourist destination. The
key attractions will be elevator rides to the top of historic launch towers
where tourists can relive the bravery of the astronauts and view the great
achievements that were the rockets. The towers and launch pads will be
reconstructed with modern corrosion-resistant materials. Actual rockets
from Rocket Park can be used, or new mockups could be built. Eventually
a monorail or maglev tour will bring tourists to the tower sites. The maglev
can eventually connect to other maglev routes to be built around KSC and
Florida to demonstrate the technology as a way to improve US transportation.
For long-term preservation, the towers and rockets will be enclosed in
transparent, climate-controlled, reinforced geodesic domes.
History and Philosophy
From earliest beginnings in 1950 to the conclusion of
Apollo in 1975, Cape Canaveral and Kennedy Space Center were sites for
the golden age of space exploration. Cape Canaveral also hosts sites where
some of the arms race was manifested as intercontinental ballistic missiles
were developed and tested. The best and the worst possibilities for the
future, opening space and waging a nuclear war, came to a focus at this
key location in time and space. Both these stories can be told as the early
satellite, Mercury, Gemini, Apollo and Shuttle pads, as well as ICBM row
and other militarily historic pads are opened for the first time to tell
their full story. Preserving and displaying the launch pads, where all
this history took place, will remind Americans and the world of the future
and the past. The political turmoil, which swamped the Apollo program,
has passed. The arms race too, is largely passed. And now the opportunity
can exist to take stock, and press on. Yes Apollo met Kennedy’s goal of
landing on the Moon by the end of the sixties, but the implications of
his goal have not been met. We have not continued to send humans beyond
low Earth orbit, to continue the "long-range exploration of space" which
Kennedy said was the importance beyond the Moon-landing goal. The future
still beckons, to return to the Moon and on to Mars.
Monorail Space Station
At the South side of the KSC Visitors Center parking lot,
is the Monorail Space Station. Gone are the boring diesel buses. An enclosed
moving walkway from the east side of the Visitors Center takes tourists
over to the Monorail Station. It is rather like the Monorail entrance at
Disney World. But it also features a large elevated viewing platform where
guests can stand and look with built-in binoculars or viewing scopes towards
the launch pads at Cape Canaveral and KSC. There will be several monorail
tracks at the station, to handle several cars. Rather than being arranged
horizontally, these tracks will be vertically and horizontally spaced.
This will present a sense of scale. This monorail station might also be
along the West or East side of the lot. The viewing platform will be above
these tracks, to give the widest possible vista. Some distance away all
the tracks from the station will approach the same height and then merge.
Car Design
The monorail cars will be sleek and futuristic. They will be large to accommodate a large group for efficiency of logistics. Since the purpose of the monorail tour is to give views and vistas, the cars will have clear sides and tops. Doors will open on only one side for safety purposes. Walls at the stations will prevent any access to the tracks once the cars depart, again for safety purposes. Each seat will feature a full-back cushion and padded headrest, fully adjustable with utmost consideration for ergonomics. Each monorail vehicle will be named after one of the original astronauts from Mercury, Gemini and Apollo.
Launch Pad Layout
The launch pads will be reconstructed where they originally
were. This is more historically interesting than reconstructing them elsewhere,
including being near the original blockhouses. However the Pad 39 is still
in use, so the Saturn tower would be difficult or impossible to restore
there. In addition the original Redstone, Atlas and Titan pads are also
fairly near some operational launch pads, so there may be interference
there and also the risk of damage to the historic pads by any launch accidents.
But launches there are not very frequent, so the monorail tours would not
be contstrained so much by that.
Another alternative might be to reconstruct the launch
pads in a straight line along the unused portion of Cape Canaveral Air
Force Station or the wildlife refuge north of KSC. But both of these present
problems—possible interference with Cape Canaveral Air Force Station or
valid environmental objections to destroying the wildlife refuge.
Yet another option is to put all these reconstructed pads
and towers along the West shore of the Banana River. This would be closer
to the KSC Visitors Center and would not interfere with any of the Cape
Canaveral Air Force Station operations.
Launch Pad Features
Not only will the launch towers be in place, but ancillary
towers too, the ones that fit against the main tower for additional vehicle
servicing. These will not be closed in normally, but can be on rails to
move back and forth just as the real ones did. This will include the Saturn
V Mobile Servicing Structure, the Titan erectable service structure and
the Atlas and Redstone gantries.
Where feasible, existing structures will be restored.
A Redstone tower is still in place at the Air Force Space Museum. This
will be refurbished to exactly replicate the manned version. Some Titan
structures still remain, but do have rusting. The primary structure to
be restored in this project is the original Launch Umbilical Tower from
Apollo 11. This sits in sections still on KSC land. The sections can be
moved only by dismantling and trucking or by using railways that may already
exist.
In addition to the launch towers and rockets, the launch
pads will be rebuilt. This includes the Atlas base, Titan base, Pad 34
base and the enormous Saturn V base of Pad 39A. The trucking in or barging
in of the enormous quantities of sand for the Saturn V makes this one of
the biggest jobs of the whole effort. This could be done in stages though.
A platform of the right height made from concrete could start the job.
The pad would gradually fill in around this platform while the mobile launch
platform and tower were built atop it.
Where to Build the Saturn Pad
Rather than rebuilding the huge Pad 39A base, the original
one may be used. One possibility is that Pads 39A and 39B will be retired
when the Shuttle is eventually replaced around the year 2010 to 2020. It
would be a big decision to do this, for it would mean most likely that
the VAB would be retired as well. This represents an enormous infrastructure
for large vehicles, so it is not likely to happen. But if this did happen,
Pad 39A could be rebuilt in its exact Apollo configuration while Pad 39B
could be left in its Shuttle configuration. Both vehicles could be replicated
as well, or an actual Shuttle could be used for its pad. Before domes might
be constructed, the VAB could serve as a safe haven for these vehicles
during storms and extreme weather.
Should the next generation of launch vehicles be using
the VAB and Pad 39 facilities, another location for the Saturn and Shuttle
pad replicas must be chosen. Again the West bank of the Banana River is
one site. A location near the Saturn V Center museum might also be good.
Yet that is rather close to the Shuttle landing strip, which will be still
active. Another option is to simply park the Mobile Launch Platforms with
vehicles near the VAB. However, no safe haven would exist and building
of domes would be difficult with not a lot of room there.
Monorail Track Layout and Typical Tour
The monorail leaves the Visitors Center gates going east
and out along the NASA Causeway, then runs South for several miles, then
turns left towards the first pads on the tour. The figure below shows the
route. At this turn, there is an optional turn towards Port Canaveral and
the tourist ships. Indeed the monorail system will serve to link to these
ships for tourist transportation from Titusville.
This route shown is not the only option. The route could
for instance be built along the west bank of the Banana River. It could
also be split into two or more routes, much like the separate Canaveral
and KSC tours that used to be in place. This route is chosen because the
initial view going across the Causeway is going to be more spectacular.
First Stop, Mercury Redstone, Pad 5 and 6
The first Monorail stop occurs as ICBM Row comes into
view. The monorail pulls alongside the Redstone gantry at Pads 5 and 6.
A short narration describes the flights of Shepard and Grissom. Guests
disembark and walk through the White Room there. Tour guides give a description
while white room personnel fit a silver-suited astronaut into the capsule.
This stop also includes a visit to the pad and gantry for Explorer 1, the
first American satellite and a Jupiter C, the rocket that launched it.
A Vanguard rocket and pad will also be viewed here. If possible replica
pads and rockets from Robert Goddard’s pioneering efforts will also be
constructed. A V2 pad will also be shown, though perhaps this will be constructed
in place on Pad 1. The Cape Canaveral Lighthouse will also be a feature
to see or stop at. This first phase of the tour will give viewers a good
sense for how it all began.
Second Stop, Mercury Atlas, Pad 14
The monorail leaves for the Mercury Atlas pad while the
onboard announcer talks about the flights of Glenn, Carpenter, Schirra
and Cooper. The same capsule demonstration happens there. The monorail
stops at each pad for a similar ride up the elevator to the capsule or
crew cabin. Each launch pad facility is enclosed fully within a glass/plastic
clear geodesic dome. The domes have large doors through which the monorails
enter smoothly. Stairways and escalators take the visitors from the monorail
down to ground level at the base of the pads. They enter elevators there
that carry them up to the cabin level.
Tourist Traffic Flow Questions
One issue about this is: how can a monorail full of people
fit into a pad elevator for the capsule tours? A White Room and the elevator
can hold perhaps ten people at the most comfortably. Yet a monorail will
have 50 people. One answer is to take turns. Ten people at a time will
go up the elevator while the remaining 40 can be exploring the base of
the pad. Or perhaps five will go up the elevator each time. Each group
will get to spend ten minutes at the pad this way, so that each pad visit
takes 50 minutes or 100 minutes, for example. Another answer is to have
the monorail itself stop at the capsule level and disembark the passengers
at a specially constructed platform that leads to the capsule-level of
the tower. Then everyone can be viewing from this level while five to ten
at a time go over into the White Room. This will eliminate the time going
up the elevator. This option is best for the lower pads of Mercury and
Gemini, but is unrealistic for Apollo Saturn 1 or Saturn V. For these pads,
a new elevator tower could be built alongside the existing tower, or the
servicing structures could be used to hide newly built larger elevators.
These elevators could take 50 at a time up to the capsule level where again
smaller groups can enter into the White Room.
Groups and functions can also be accommodated. People
will also be able to spend a whole day visiting just one pad if they wish.
The concept of the traffic flow question though, is to provide a guided
experience, not to have these be national monuments, but more of a learning
environment. It is expected that most tourists will take these guided tours
which see all the pads in one tour.
Third Stop, Gemini Titan, Pad 19
Next the monorail will stop at Pad 19, where all the Gemini
missions were launched. Here the Titan and capsule can be seen. At the
White room level, two astronaut actors will demonstrate how they entered
the capsule. An Agena target vehicle will also be on display in the complex.
Several cars from the year 1965 will be placed around, as if pad workers
were out on a lunch break.
Fourth Stop, Apollo Saturn 1B, Pad 34
The next stop ahead will be where the true scale of the
Moon Race becomes evident. Here too the human story of effort and sacrifice
are told. For the Saturn 1B is truly a giant compared to Titan 2. This
is also where the crew of Apollo 1 were tragically killed in the capsule
fire during a ground test. This story will be told at the pad, and there
will be no elevator ride at this one.
Fifth Stop, Apollo Saturn V, Pad 39A or Replica
The culmination of the Moon race comes next into view,
the 363-foot tall Saturn V atop a giant Mobile Launch Platform, with Launch
Umbilical Tower and Mobile Service Structure. The monorail rides at an
incline as it comes up to pad level atop the launch base. Passengers disembark
and are allowed to walk around on the top of the Mobile Launch Platform.
From there they are all taken as one up elevators to capsule level. These
will be new larger elevators added to the sides of the tower, or a separate
new tower that takes them slowly up to the top as the view gets higher
and higher.
Sixth Stop, Space Shuttle, Pad 39B or Replica
Finally the tour will move on to present day, the near
past and near future as the Space Shuttle on Pad 39B or a replica. The
monorail will approach and stop at the pad in a different route than at
the Saturn V, so that a different experience will be given. Perhaps the
monorail will pull up alongside the fixed service structure half way up,
and the tourists can explore the tower from there. The rotating service
structure will be in the open position. An option will exist to close the
structure and open the Shuttle payload bay doors.
Dome Features
At each dome, there will be a gift shop, restrooms, a
restaurant, a movie theater for 100 people, and museum display. It will
be very much like the features of the Saturn V Center.
The geodesic dome structure will be fairly simple for
the smaller pads, but for the Saturns and Shuttle, some larger features
are needed. The Saturn V dome is the largest, and will be 500 feet in radius.
It will be made from main trusses 25 feet long. Three of these are joined
to make a triangle. An inverted triangle is completed next to it, and so
on. First the ground layer of triangles are laid down. Atop these the next
layer are added. The domes are built from the ground up this way, and are
self-supporting during construction. Inside the outer layer is a second
layer formed by additional trusses forming an icosahedron (3-D triangle).
The tips of these on the inside are also joined together, forming the inner
dome layer. Thus the 500-foot tall dome will have a skin 25-feet thick.
The outer dome trusses then feature glass-or plastic supporting features.
First there will be a network of 5-foot triangles (or whatever the size
is that fits) within the 25-foot ones. These smaller triangles will each
hold a pane of glass or plastic. The glass will not simply slip into a
slot in the trusses, but will have a fairing over the slot, to keep out
rain and sun. Over this fairing and below will be a gasket, and on top
of the gasket protective layers of material. The dome will be designed
to last centuries and protect the pads from hurricane, sun, rain and frost.
Along the inner layer of the dome, will be strips of solar
panels, generating electricity that is stored in batteries to assist in
running the air conditioners and more. The strips of solar panels will
not block the sunlight or view much, but instead simply cover the outside-facing
surfaces of the dome inner struts. It may be more optimum to have glass
that can darken in daytime, in which case the solar panels could be on
the outer struts, built in such a way as to be well sealed beneath glass.
Should the dome be built first, a crane can be mounted
in the roof, for hoisting pad components into place. Otherwise the pads
can be built using standard construction cranes. The domes can be built
next with these cranes, or a crane unit can be designed to traverse the
ever-rising dome top and then be lowered down from the center as the last
piece of the dome cap is put in place.
Geodesic domes are often viewed as fragile things, but
these ones will be extremely tough and protective. They will be based in
a perimeter of concrete or steel, several feet high to provide protection
against hurricane-force tidal waves. The plastic or glass will be thick
enough to withstand hurricanes. The domes will have double or triple layers
of reinforced truss-work to support themselves against stresses.
It would be best for the monorails to enter directly into
the interior of the domes (when built). This way the tourists will enjoy
an enclosed environment at all times, during hot Florida summers and cold
winters.
Simulated Countdown
Part of the pad experience will be a simulated countdown.
A huge PA system will reply actual recordings from a launch of the vehicle
of the type shown in the dome. Dry ice (carefully metered to maintain dome
oxygen) will simulate cryo boiloff. As T-0 is reached, the PA system will
generate significant decibels to thrill the audience. A large smoke machine
and bright lights to simulate flames might also be used, but this is probably
not feasible unless the glass windows can be opened, and even then would
depend on prevailing wind directions.
Capsule and Crew Cabin Visits
A feature of the tour will be the visit to the white room.
Ideally there might be a way for every tourist to also get an opportunity
to actually climb into the cabin. For Mercury capsules, this will be only
available to people who are small enough. For Apollo, most people could
fit inside. If the tour is busy as expected, there may be no way to let
everyone do this. So a raffle of each monorail car could determine who
gets to do this. While the raffle winners sit in the capsule chairs (one
for Mercury, two for Gemini, three for Apollo, and seven for Shuttle),
audio from a countdown would be playing inside, and a guide could be describing
the cabin to them via audio.
In addition to access to capsules up on the rockets, a
number of capsule simulators can be built on the ground near the pad, and
this will allow many people to have a seat inside to see how the original
astronauts lived. These might even feature motion-based rides and realistic
movement of control panel dials and lights, with piped-in radio messages.
Jolts during a simulated launch would replicate the experience of stage
separations. Mercury, Gemini and Apollo capsules would be available. The
blockhouses and launch control centers could also be replicated. Families
and groups can split up duties and some can go into the capsule while the
rest participate as launch control. They'll each get a script they can
read from following a taped launch countdown. Inside the capsule, the family
members can be clothed in simulated Mercury, Gemini or Apollo space suits.
A few minutes before launch, there would be a moment for the ground crews
to send their best wishes for a safe launch, and for the astronauts to
reply. At launch the capsules will move about as sound levels are simulated
and window views and instruments move. In the launch control center, a
launch will be visible through simulated windows, much like the Saturn
V launch simulation at the Saturn V Center at KSC.
Photographs and Mementos
Another feature of the tour will be photographs. A modern
digital camera system and printer will allow everyone to have an instant
picture taken. These can also be emailed as files to their homes. Examples
of photos are: at the base of the tower looking up, at the top looking
down, standing alongside the crew cabin, sitting inside the cabin, and
so on. Realistic-looking space suits could also be rented for them to try
on for a photo. A DVD can also be recorded of each complete tour highlights.
Slide Wire Ride
Adventurous types would have the option of taking a safety
ride down the emergency egress slide wire. Enterprising pad crews who found
a safe and fast way to escape from any pad emergencies put these in place
in the original pads. The cables led from the launch tower to a safe haven
on the ground some distance away. The tourist would suit up, strap on,
step off and enjoy a long slide to the ground. A TV transmitter camera
in their helmet would beam their view back to a monitor up at the pad for
the rest of the tourists to watch along.
Safety Concerns
Most people are not used to riding an open-air elevator
up to 400 feet. Medical people will be available at each launch pad. People
will be told before the ride starts that they can stop it at any time and
ride a backup elevator back down. At each level of the launch pads, fencing
will totally enclose the outside walls. An inner rail will be added that
is a foot or two from this fence. The original rails at the wall will also
still be included. Thus two rails plus a complete fence will prevent falls.
Security will also be present to be called upon as required.
Blockhouses
The blockhouses and launch control centers would be replicated
in this project. Much of the Saturn launch control center has been removed.
This could be replicated and the room rebuilt in full at the Saturn V Center.
Ther Mercury Mission Control Center still exists, and will continue to
be maintained. The blockhouse at Pad 26 would be restored to original configuration
and the museum that is there would be relocated in a new facility.
Construction Phasing
There are five elements to the construction project: the
monorail, the pads, the rockets, the towers and the domes. All five make
it an exciting tourist destination. The domes alone are non-essential.
These could be added later. Their primary benefit is the climate control.
This helps bring tourists during summer and winter. They also help preserve
the project against the salt corrosion environment and sunlight. Funding
for the domes could be derived from operations later. The pads could also
be omitted, with only the towers in place. But the pads really are essential
to showing just what the original setup was, including the huge Pad 39
bases.
The first thing to do is rebuild Pad 14, Mercury Redstone.
This will be relatively inexpensive because the base is still present,
only requiring refurbishment. The tower and service gantry are gone. These
were put out to sea. It is not likely that they can be retrieved and restored,
but this option will be reviewed. The plans are available and a suitable
replica can be rebuilt. This should be done first because it encapsulates
the entire tour concept in a meaningful way early on. But mostly, this
should be done first because the original Mercury astronauts who launched
from there can be invited to preside over the opening ceremonies: Glenn,
Carpenter, Schirra and Cooper.
The second project will be to preserve the Apollo 11 Launch
Umbilical Tower to protect it against further erosion. Presently it is
in an outdoor area at KSC, where it has rested since it was dismantled
in 1983. If needed, a steel building or an inflatable stadium tent will
be placed over the tower to provide an air-conditioned environment.
While the Apollo tower is being preserved, the other smaller
pads can be completed. This will include the Redstone, Jupiter C and Gemini
Titan pads. The Mercury astronauts can also come to commemmorate Shepard
and Grissom at the Redstone pad opening. Gemini crews can come for a reunion
to the Pad 19 grand opening.
Finally Pad 34, and Pad 39 can be completed. Pad 34 will
feature a dedication ceremony attended by all the Apollo astronauts and
program participants. A round platform below the rocket at the center of
the pad will be added, where people can place flowers and other mementos
to pay their respects. Pad 39 for Saturn and Shuttle will be done at a
place and time that depends on the future of the Shuttle program. Either
they will be elsewhere on KSC, or done in place on the current pads.
Tie-In to the Rest of KSC, Port Canaveral, Astronaut Hall of Fame, Space Camp and Titusville
The main attraction will be the launch pad tours, but
the monorail tour could also make connections to the Saturn V Center, the
VAB and LCC, the pad 39 viewing station. As mentioned before, another leg
would go down through to Port Canaveral. Ideally the monorail would connect
back to Titusville, to bring tourists in from hotels there. There would
also be a stop at the Astronaut Hall of Fame and Space Camp, from where
young astronauts would embark for their launches. The maglev monorail will
be a prototype for a Florida-wide transportation system.
Issues
If any of the Cape Canaveral pads are to be rebuilt, the
Air Force would have to agree and provide access. They and NASA would have
to finally decide to declare the particular pad deactivated. Pad 5 is already
so, the site of the Air Force Space Museum. The Mercury Atlas and Gemini
Titan pads have also been left unused for nearly 40 years. So these could
be rebuilt in place and would be a key part of the tour--as well as accurising
the tower at Pad 5. A monorail route would be pretty secure, so should
not be a security concern, but the passengers would have to be screened
and protected just as on an airplane by going through a security checkpoint.
If multiple pads are converted to exhibits, an issue is the appearance
that the place is a museum more than an operational launch site. There
is plenty of land though, and there are lots of active pads in use. Pad
workers and Cape workers may also not appreciate tourists constantly streaming
by in monorails while they work. Most of the industrial areas will be some
distance from the monorails, and there are not a lot of pad workers at
most times. Indeed it is hoped that retired and active pad workers will
volunteer to man the exhibit pads and share their experiences as they wish.
Ideally this will be a learning environment for people,
and a benefit to pad workers as well. Funds from the operation can go to
preserving additional pads, but also if sufficient to upkeep on the operational
pads. This project will only happen if it is a win-win scenario for all
concerned.
There are only three main active pads at Cape Canaveral:
Pad 17 for Deltas, Pad 36 for Atlas, and Pad 37 for future Delta 4. All
the other pads have been dismantled, or otherwise abandoned. These are
all candidates for restoration. Not all of them would require the monorail
to stop, but to have them visible would add to the tour, and detailed tours
could stop there.
Peace activists may object to making a monument out of
missile sites, but these missiles did protect the world. The people that
worked at this were protecting us all. When people see the might we had,
and that yet we did not use it in anger, the peaceful intentions of America
will also be evident.
Another issue is wear and tear on the launch pads created
by lots of tourists. One solution is to build two copies of each launch
tower. Perhaps one would be the original tower, with as much original material
as possible. The other copy would be a replica, perhaps located back near
the KSC Visitors Center for ease of access, or along the West bank of the
Banana River.
All-Access Pass
While there will be guided tours, the option exists to
stop at any pad for as long as one wishes. Not all the passengers will
have to stay with each car. So it is best if the monorail pass be a "day
pass" and one can get on and off in any order one wishes.
Architectural Design of New Buildings
All the architecture associated with the monorail tour
and other new additions be extremely futuristic in appearance. This fits
with how the space program was seen in the early days. It would be some
fulfillment of that. Yet it should not be garish. The feeling should be
that the future has arrived and also the hopes for the future are being
expressed again. There should be competitions among architects to get the
balance just right, between how we envision future buildings today and
how future buildings were imagined in the 50's and 60's.
Budget
Here is a first approximation at the budget for this project.
|
|
(millions) |
Revenues |
Expenses |
| 5/6, Mercury Redstone | 2 | 0.25 | 0.1 |
| 14, Mercury Atlas | 10 | 1 | 0.5 |
| 19, Gemini Titan | 10 | 1 | 0.5 |
| 34, Apollo Saturn 1B | 40 | 2 | 1 |
| 39, Apollo Saturn V | 80 | 10 | 2 |
| Total | 142 | 14.25 | 4.1 |
This is for the pads, towers and rockets only. The monorail
has been budgeted for about 600 million. The domes would probably cost
200 million later. The whole thing is close to a billion when done. The
monorail pays for itself as it expands to serve the rest of Florida (they
are a separate entity). The core project will take about 30 years to pay
off the startup from projected revenues. Ten years will pay for the pads,
so maybe after about ten years of operation the domes could actually be
added. Perhaps the smaller domes could be put in earlier. In addition,
the project would raise more funds and use revenue to rebuild more of the
Air Force pads on Canaveral.
Schedule
If all funding were available, the pads would be built
in parallel and complete tours could begin when done. This would take three
to four years. With incremental funding beginning today, an opening schedule
might look more like this:
Pad 19 Opens 2005
Pad 5/6 Opens 2006
Pad 34 Opens 2007
Monorail In Place 2008
Pad 39 Saturn 2010
Pad 39 Shuttle 2012
Pad 5/6 Dome 2013
Pad 14 Dome 2014
Pad 19 Dome 2014
Pad 34 Dome 2015
Pad 39 Saturn Dome 2017
Pad 39 Shuttle Dome 2018
Conclusion
This concept includes:
Moving Redstone, Atlas, Titan and Saturn rockets or replicas to the pads
Elevator rides to capsule levels on the towers
Conducting monorail tours that stop at each pad
Building domes over the pads to protect them and allow
year-round comfortable tours.
Fred Becker
mach25@comcast.net
7-19-02